Raw milk debate to heat up after today’s $30K prosecution

by | May 5, 2022 | News

A Horowhenua milk business, MannaMilk has been fined $30,000 for not following the rules that regulate the supply and sale of raw milk.

Following a successful prosecution by New Zealand Food Safety, Manakau based MannaMilk owner John Albert Martin (78) was today sentenced in the Levin District Court. Mr Martin earlier pleaded guilty to 3 charges under the Animal Products Act, including failing to follow raw milk regulations, selling raw milk, and failing to comply with a notice of direction to cease processing and selling raw milk.

“We expect today’s sentence sends a strong message to all dairy farmers involved in raw milk production,” says New Zealand Food Safety deputy director general Vincent Arbuckle.

“Raw milk is inherently much more of a food safety risk than milk that has been pasteurised to kill potentially harmful bacteria.

“Producers owe it to their customers to follow the rules and take every required precaution to ensure the safety of their product. There is less risk of a person becoming ill from drinking raw milk products when they do.”

Raw milk producers must register with New Zealand Food Safety, meet hygiene requirements, test milk for pathogens, keep records of sales, and label appropriately so consumers were aware of the risks and could make informed decisions about consuming raw milk.

In early 2019 New Zealand Food Safety carried out an investigation, called Operation Caravan, to ensure farmers were following regulations in place to protect consumers.

Mr Martin attempted to avoid the regulations by distributing raw milk to customers through a separate legal entity and claiming it was not for sale.

Our investigation found Mr Martin ignored a previous Notice of Direction to cease sales and continued to sell product illegally both through the legal entity and direct to customers.

“Mr Martin went to some lengths to avoid his responsibilities under the law. By contrast most raw milk producers follow the rules and find it easy to do so.

“Compliance with the rules would have cost his company MannaMilk $10,000 to $15,000 a year, a small amount next to the $243,000 MannaMilk made in 2019,” says New Zealand Food Safety deputy director general Vincent Arbuckle.

New Zealand Food Safety has further cases involving the illegal sales of raw milk that will be placed before the court.


Photo by The Humble Co. on Unsplash

About the Author


Related Posts

New reports highlight food recall system at work

New reports highlight food recall system at work

A new report by New Zealand Food Safety (NZFS) identifies Salmonella in imported sesame seed-based products as the most significant food safety event of 2023, resulting in 14 recalls affecting 65 food products. The Consumer-level Food Recalls Annual Report for 2023,...

Poor uptake makes mockery of Health Star Ratings system

Poor uptake makes mockery of Health Star Ratings system

The voluntary Health Star Rating (HSR) system must urgently be made mandatory to ensure New Zealanders can make easy, healthy choices at the supermarket, according to Health Coalition Aotearoa. Just released analysis by University of Auckland researchers found 30.4...